Loading IndicatorLoading Indicator

Goldman Sees KOSPI at 7,500, Morgan Stanley at 10,000, Leaving Retail Investors Confused

Source
Korea Economic Daily

Summary

  • Goldman Sachs said it cut its 12-month KOSPI target to 7,500 from 9,000 while maintaining its overweight rating.
  • Morgan Stanley said KOSPI 10,000 could become a sustainable new benchmark within three to five years, forecasting the arrival of a Korea Renaissance.
  • Investors said they are confused about what to use as a benchmark for investment decisions because of conflicting forecasts based on concern over a peak in memory semiconductors and growth in the AI industry, respectively.

Forecast Trend Report by Period

Loading IndicatorLoading Indicator

Goldman Sachs cuts KOSPI target to 7,500 from 9,000

Morgan Stanley says KOSPI above 10,000 would herald a 'Korea Renaissance'

Photo: Shutterstock
Photo: Shutterstock

Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley have issued starkly different views on the medium- to long-term outlook for South Korea's stock market. Goldman has repeatedly lowered its KOSPI target, citing market doubts over the durability of the memory-chip boom and slowing earnings momentum. Morgan Stanley, by contrast, said expanded investment in artificial intelligence, industrial restructuring and capital-market reforms could entrench a KOSPI 10,000 era within three to five years.

Goldman Sachs cuts KOSPI ceiling to 7,500 as memory doubts deepen

According to the financial investment industry on Nov. 18, Goldman Sachs said in a report published a day earlier that it cut its 12-month KOSPI target by 16.7% to 7,500 from 9,000. The move came about three weeks after it lowered the target to 9,000 from 12,000 on Oct. 25. Goldman had maintained its 12,000 target for about five months after setting it on June 3.

John Kwon, a Goldman Sachs analyst, said volatility in South Korea's stock market has risen in the second half of this year while the pace of upward revisions to earnings forecasts has slowed. Against that backdrop, he wrote, Goldman lowered its KOSPI target because the market still appears reluctant to fully price in corporate fundamentals.

Goldman said earnings-per-share growth forecasts for South Korean companies excluding Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix have retreated from recent highs. Forecast EPS growth for this year, excluding memory-chip makers, rose from 28% in January to 84% last month before edging down to 81% this month. The forecast for next year climbed to 20% in July and August, then fell to 18% in September and 15% in October.

Goldman said the shortage in memory-chip supply could continue through 2028 and may last until 2030. Even so, it expects EPS growth at Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix to slow to 5% and 13% in 2028 from 64% and 47% next year, respectively.

The bank said market anxiety that the semiconductor boom could end sooner than expected is limiting upside for South Korean stocks. If investor doubts over the durability of the memory upcycle persist, Kwon said, share prices could remain below levels supported by corporate profitability.

Even so, Goldman kept its overweight rating, saying South Korean equities remain deeply undervalued. Based on market earnings estimates, a KOSPI level of 7,500 would imply a forward price-to-earnings ratio of 4.9 times and a price-to-book ratio of 1.18 times. Goldman said that even at 7,500, the index would still trade more than 40% below fair value based on the historical relationship between an expected return on equity of 24% and PBR.

Kwon said that even using a conservative valuation at a KOSPI target of 7,500, the index would still offer an expected 12-month total return of about 50% in dollar terms.

Morgan Stanley says South Korea is a key country enabling the AI revolution

Morgan Stanley took the opposite view, saying the KOSPI could rise above 10,000 within the next three to five years and settle there as a sustainable level. The bank said a structural rerating of South Korea's economy and stock market — a "Korea Renaissance" — is on the way.

In a Nov. 11 report titled "Beyond the Miracle on the Han River: Korea Renaissance Is Coming," Morgan Stanley analysts Joon Seok, Kathleen Oh, the firm's head of Korea and Taiwan research, and Shawn Kim, known in South Korea for his bearish semiconductor calls, laid out that view.

The analysts said the KOSPI is now in the middle of a rerating process. Over the next three to five years, improving fundamentals and technical conditions could support substantial further rerating, they wrote. They added that a KOSPI level above 10,000 could become a durable new benchmark rather than a temporary peak.

Morgan Stanley said the main drivers of a long-term rally in South Korean stocks would be a strategic industrial shift centered on AI, defense and energy, an economic lift from the semiconductor boom, and reforms to capital markets and corporate governance. On that basis, the bank expects return on equity at South Korean companies to rise to 13.5% to 14.5% by 2030 from about 8% historically, while price-to-book ratios expand to 1.5 to 1.6 times.

Morgan Stanley also pointed to heavy semiconductor capital spending as a key factor lifting South Korea's growth potential. It expects combined annual capital expenditure by Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix to rise to more than $120.1 billion this year from an average of $39.5 billion over the past decade. Cumulative investment is projected to reach about $2.5 trillion by 2035.

The bank also expects AI infrastructure spending to keep expanding. "South Korea is not simply a country participating in the AI industry, but a key country making the AI revolution possible," Morgan Stanley said. It expects stronger investment and productivity gains to help South Korea post annual economic growth in the low-3% range through 2030. The bank also said the total shareholder return ratio of South Korean companies could rise to 50% to 60% within three to five years, supporting a rerating of the market.

Investors appeared uncertain about how to position themselves amid the conflicting calls. One retail investor said even local brokerages are split on the KOSPI outlook, and the gap between Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley has made it difficult to know which research should guide investment decisions. With one side citing fears of a peak in memory semiconductors and the other pointing to AI-driven growth, investors are bound to feel confused, the person said.

Kang Kyung-ju, Hankyung.com reporter memory@hankyung.com

#AI
#Semiconductor
#KOSPI
Korea Economic Daily

Korea Economic Daily

hankyung@bloomingbit.ioThe Korea Economic Daily Global is a digital media where latest news on Korean companies, industries, and financial markets.

What do you think about this news?

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌

PiCK News

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌

Hashtag News

‌
‌
‌
‌