Loading IndicatorLoading Indicator

Analyst Behind 70,000-Won Samsung, 200,000-Won SK Hynix Calls Warns Shares Could Slide Again

Source
Korea Economic Daily

Summary

  • Analyst Lee Joo-wan said Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix have fair values of 70,000 won and 200,000 won, respectively, and that their shares could plunge if memory prices decline.
  • He said the memory supercycle has already passed its peak, that this year's third-quarter earnings and operating margins were the peak, and warned that memory prices could fall as much as 90% going forward.
  • Lee said the current stock rally is abnormal and that because earnings improvement has been driven only by higher prices, investor anxiety is growing that the current earnings boom could mark the final peak before a stock-price decline.

Forecast Trend Report by Period

Loading IndicatorLoading Indicator

"The real plunge hasn't started yet"

Analyst issues stark warning on 70,000-won Samsung, 200,000-won SK Hynix outlook


"The memory supercycle has already passed its peak"

"The current stock rally is abnormal"

Photo: Shutterstock
Photo: Shutterstock

An analyst who has set fair-value targets for Samsung Electronics Co. and SK Hynix Inc. at 70,000 won and 200,000 won, respectively, warned that their shares could tumble again once memory-chip prices begin to weaken. He argued that the memory supercycle has already passed its peak, with third-quarter results this year effectively marking the high point.

On Nov. 20, Lee Joo-wan, an industry analyst and former senior researcher at SK Hynix, said on the YouTube channel Jisikhankkeut that "the full-scale plunge hasn't started yet." Share selloffs in memory-chip companies begin when prices start to fall. On his targets for Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix, he added that his view was unchanged and that "they have no choice but to go there."

Lee said that once news begins to emerge late this year or early next year that memory prices are falling in earnest, brokerages will rush to sharply cut earnings estimates for memory companies for next year and the following year. He also argued that the memory cycle had already peaked in the third quarter and that operating margins at the three major memory makers probably peaked in that period.

As for the scale of the decline, he said that once memory prices start falling, they drop 50% within a year and 90% within two years. "That's the pace investors should expect," he said.

He also argued that the recent earnings improvement at chipmakers was driven not by higher output but by rising prices. Share prices began climbing in April last year, when memory prices also started to rise. Earnings improved solely because prices increased. Production and shipments are the same now as they were a year ago, he said, adding that for a manufacturer, unchanged output means the company has not grown at all.

On Nvidia Corp., Lee said the company is now in bubble territory because a market in which Nvidia effectively forced supplier demand has lasted for three years. He dismissed the current rise in its stock price as an abnormal rally with no connection to the cycle.

Lee drew attention in October when he set fair-value targets for Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix at 70,000 won and 200,000 won, respectively. At the time, he said stock prices reflect a company's future value, while earnings reflect current value. The market is questioning whether 107 trillion won ($76.9 billion) will still be possible a year from now, and he said he believes that is absolutely impossible.

Investors who saw the remarks are expressing concern over further downside. One investor wrote in an online stock discussion forum that he had initially thought the call for Samsung Electronics at 70,000 won and SK Hynix at 200,000 won made no sense, but now thinks the warning could become reality as brokerages' earnings forecasts appear to be losing credibility. If the memory supercycle has indeed passed its peak, the current earnings boom may instead be the final top before a share-price decline, the investor wrote.

Samsung Electronics was trading at 183,800 won as of 12:50 p.m., down 6.65% from the previous session, while SK Hynix fell 6.59% to 1.105 million won.

Kang Kyung-ju, Hankyung.com reporter memory@hankyung.com

#Semiconductor
Korea Economic Daily

Korea Economic Daily

hankyung@bloomingbit.ioThe Korea Economic Daily Global is a digital media where latest news on Korean companies, industries, and financial markets.

What do you think about this news?

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌

PiCK News

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌

Hashtag News

‌
‌
‌
‌