Wall Street Hit by ‘Black Christmas’ Fears; Goldman Says S&P 500 Could Drop Another 9% on 2018-Like Path
Summary
- Goldman Sachs said the S&P 500 could fall about 9% from current levels if it follows the same path as it did in late 2018.
- JPMorgan said there has been no rebound despite heavy selling by hedge funds and trend-following funds, and that the risk of additional selling by long-term capital remains.
- Cathay Securities in Taiwan said investors should watch whether December could mark the final rate increase and whether the PCE price index and the FOMC become a turning point for the market.
Forecast Trend Report by Period



A warning of a “Black Christmas” has hit the U.S. stock market. With equities failing to rebound despite heavy hedge-fund selling, investors are drawing comparisons to 2018, when fears over Federal Reserve tightening fed a year-end plunge.
On Nov. 21, Goldman Sachs’ trading desk said the S&P 500 could fall to 6,294 if the market follows the same path as it did in late 2018. That would be about 9% below its Nov. 20 close of 6,910.39. Goldman noted that the market bottomed 65 trading days after its peak in that episode, versus 33 trading days so far this time. On the same timeline, the low could come in the first week of January.
The lack of buying after the selloff is adding to market anxiety. JPMorgan said hedge funds and trend-following funds had sold to levels that would have sparked a rebound in past episodes, yet no bounce has appeared this time. The bank added that long-term money, including pension funds and asset managers, is still positioned for rising stock prices, leaving open the possibility of further selling.
Goldman Sachs’ panic index has risen to 9.8 out of 10. While there have been past cases in which stress eased after the gauge moved above 9.5, some on Wall Street say a rebound does not necessarily signal the end of the decline. JPMorgan cited 2018 as an example, when stocks briefly rebounded in late November before falling further through Christmas Eve.
The earnings outlook, however, is different from that period. S&P 500 earnings per share were flat in 2019, but are forecast to rise 14% next year. With earnings estimates holding up even as stock prices slide sharply, the direction of interest rates is emerging as the main variable for any recovery in investor sentiment.
The U.S. October personal consumption expenditures price index is due on Nov. 25, and the Federal Open Market Committee is scheduled to meet on Dec. 8-9. Cathay Securities in Taiwan said December could mark the final rate increase if lower oil prices ease inflation pressure. Investors should watch whether that becomes a turning point in clearing recent headwinds.
YM Lee
20min@bloomingbit.ioCrypto Chatterbox_ tlg@Bloomingbit_YMLEE