Loading IndicatorLoading Indicator

Kalshi Faces New York Shutdown Risk After Federal Court Sends Case to State Court

Source
Suehyeon Lee

Summary

  • The US District Court for the Southern District of New York sent the Kalshi case back to New York state court, raising the possibility of a New York-ordered shutdown of operations.
  • The CFTC said Kalshi might have to shut down its entire business if its event-contract trading is stopped, but its request for a temporary restraining order was denied.
  • The conflict over regulatory authority for prediction markets is spreading across the US, with the possibility of a ruling by the US Supreme Court also being raised.

Forecast Trend Report by Period

Loading IndicatorLoading Indicator
Photo: Shutterstock
Photo: Shutterstock

US prediction-market platform Kalshi faces a greater risk of business disruption after failing to keep a lawsuit over New York state's demand that it cease operations in federal court.

CoinDesk reported on Nov. 20 that the US District Court for the Southern District of New York decided a day earlier to send New York state's case against Kalshi back to state court. The court found the dispute should be handled by a New York state court, not a federal court.

The decision clears the way for New York authorities to renew legal efforts to halt Kalshi's event-contract trading. New York argues that prediction-market trading tied to outcomes such as sports games and political elections amounts to gambling and should be subject to state regulation.

New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Kalshi in July, alleging the company was operating an illegal gambling business. The New York State Gaming Commission had previously ordered Kalshi to stop operating, but Kalshi has challenged the state's authority by arguing that it is a federally regulated exchange overseen by the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

The ruling could have broader repercussions because Kalshi is headquartered in New York. In a filing submitted to federal court on Nov. 20, the CFTC said Kalshi might have to shut down its entire business if New York stops its event-contract trading.

The CFTC also argued that the event contracts traded on Kalshi could qualify as swaps under federal commodities law and that regulatory authority over them rests with federal authorities. On that basis, it sought a temporary restraining order to block New York's move to halt the business, but the federal judge denied the request during a telephone hearing later that day.

The New York attorney general's office also submitted a proposed temporary restraining order to temporarily suspend Kalshi's trading. No actual shutdown order has been issued so far, and related legal proceedings are still ongoing.

Kalshi maintains that it has operated legally under the federal regulatory framework. "Kalshi was approved as a federally regulated exchange during the Biden administration and has complied with the law from the start," spokesperson Elizabeth Diana said. She added that the company would work with the state to find a solution that protects the interests of 1.2 million New York users.

Meanwhile, the conflict over who has authority to regulate prediction markets is spreading across the US. A third federal appeals court this week also rejected Kalshi's argument that only the CFTC has authority to regulate prediction markets. With courts reaching different conclusions, the possibility of a final ruling from the US Supreme Court on the scope of state regulatory power is also being discussed.

#Prediction Market Regulation
#Prediction Market
Suehyeon Lee

Suehyeon Lee

shlee@bloomingbit.ioI'm reporter Suehyeon Lee, your Web3 Moderator.

What do you think about this news?

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌

PiCK News

‌
‌
‌
‌
‌

Hashtag News

‌
‌
‌
‌